Undertaking Nightingale: Google accesses trove of US affected person information

A female surgeon with a tablet computerPicture copyright
Getty Photos

Picture caption

Google has entry to affected person information from 1000’s of US hospitals due to the deal


Google has gained entry to an enormous trove of US affected person information – with out the necessity to notify these sufferers – due to a take care of a significant well being agency.

The scheme, dubbed Undertaking Nightingale, was agreed with Ascension, which runs 2,600 hospitals.


Google can entry well being data, names and addresses with out telling sufferers, based on the Wall Avenue Journal, which first reported the information.

The tech large mentioned this was “normal observe”.

Among the many information Google reportedly has entry to underneath the deal are lab outcomes, diagnoses, data of hospitalisation and dates of delivery.

Neither docs nor sufferers have to be informed that Google can see this info.

The Wall Avenue Journal reviews that information entry started final 12 months and was broadened over the summer time.

In a weblog, Google mentioned its work with Ascension would adhere to industry-wide laws, such because the US Well being Insurance coverage Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 (HIPAA).

“To be clear… affected person information can’t and won’t be mixed with any Google shopper information,” the agency added.

Ascension mentioned the deal would assist it to “optimise” affected person care and would come with the event of synthetic intelligence (AI) instruments to assist docs.

The corporate additionally mentioned it will start utilizing Google’s cloud information storage service and enterprise purposes often called G Suite.

Privateness issues

Nonetheless, Undertaking Nightingale has already attracted criticism from those that argue that it takes away sufferers’ management of their very own information.

“There is a huge subject that these public-private partnerships are all carried out underneath non-public contracts, so it is fairly troublesome to get some transparency,” mentioned Prof Jane Kaye on the College of Oxford.

“Google is saying they do not hyperlink it to their different information however what they’re doing on a regular basis is refining their algorithms, refining what they do and giving them[selves] market benefit.”

Well being organisations are underneath growing strain to enhance effectivity and high quality of care. Many are turning to AI in an effort to sharpen their providers, however such strikes have typically confronted criticism over how delicate affected person information is dealt with.

Within the UK, Google’s AI-focused subsidiary DeepMind was discovered to have damaged the legislation when it failed to elucidate correctly to sufferers how their information could be used within the growth of a kidney illness app.

The device, referred to as Streams, was designed to flag up sufferers susceptible to growing acute kidney damage.