Local weather change: British Airways critiques ‘fuel-tankering’ over local weather issues

Planes at Heathrow

British Airways has launched a overview right into a money-saving apply which will increase its greenhouse fuel emissions.

It follows a BBC Panorama investigation exposing “gasoline tankering” – wherein planes are stuffed with additional gasoline, normally to keep away from paying increased costs for refuelling at vacation spot airports.


The apply may produce additional annual emissions equal to these of a big city.

BA now says that utilizing tankering to chop prices “often is the improper factor to do”.


Nonetheless, the airline added that it additionally makes use of the apply for security and operational causes, together with serving to planes to show round rapidly.

BBC Panorama has found the airline’s planes generated an additional 18,000 tonnes of carbon dioxide final 12 months via gasoline tankering.

Value financial savings made on a single flight may be as small as simply over £10 – although financial savings can run to lots of of kilos.

Researchers have estimated that one in 5 of all European flights includes some aspect of gasoline tankering.

The apply on European routes may lead to further annual greenhouse fuel emissions equal to that produced by a city of 100,000 individuals.

Critics say the widespread use of the apply undermines the aviation trade’s claims that it’s dedicated to decreasing its carbon emissions.

John Sauven, Greenpeace UK’s government director, advised the BBC this was a “traditional instance of an organization placing revenue earlier than planet”.

He added: “For this reason we will not afford one other decade of believing company greenwash and ready for the voluntary carbon reductions to look.

“We want robust laws to restrict aviation’s emissions, as a result of as long as there’s cash in polluting, they’re going to pollute as a lot as they’ll.”

Picture copyright
Getty Photographs

Picture caption

John Sauven known as for guidelines and laws to be “more durable”

Worldwide Airways Group (IAG), the corporate that owns BA, says it desires to be the world’s main airline group on sustainability.

BA boasts it even prints its in-flight journal on lighter paper to save lots of weight.

But BBC Panorama has seen dozens of inside BA paperwork that present as much as six tonnes of additional gasoline have been loaded onto planes on this manner. It has additionally seen proof that Easyjet carries additional gasoline on this manner.

Airways can lower your expenses from the truth that the worth of aviation gasoline differs between European locations.

Make a revenue

BA insiders say the corporate – like many airways operating brief haul routes in Europe – has pc software program that calculates whether or not prices may be saved by gasoline tankering.

The software program will calculate whether or not there’s a price saving to be made. If there’s, crews load up the additional gasoline.

An instance of paperwork seen by Panorama present that a latest BA flight to Italy carried practically three tonnes of additional gasoline.

British Airways proprietor IAG says strikes price £121m
British Airways flights to Cairo cancelled

The additional weight meant the airplane emitted greater than 600kg of further carbon dioxide – the identical emissions one particular person is liable for on a return flight to New York.

The price saving on that journey was lower than £40, however the paperwork Panorama has seen present that it may be even decrease than that.

IAG made an annual revenue of €2.9bn (£2.6bn) in 2018, about 80% of which got here from BA.

A BA insider described the apply as “hypocritical”.

“For such a giant firm to be attempting to save lots of such small quantities whereas emitting a lot additional CO2 appears unjustifiable within the present local weather,” he stated.

In response to the claims, the chief government of BA’s father or mother firm, IAG, introduced the airline would perform a overview of the apply.

On Friday, Willie Walsh advised buyers that the airline needed to make sure it was not “incentivising the improper behaviour” from managers.

“As a result of clearly the monetary saving would have incentivised us to do gasoline tankering,” he stated.

“However possibly… this the improper factor to do and the improper factor to incentive. So we need to be certain we’ve our incentives aligned to the best actions so guarantee monetary sustainability but in addition environmental sustainability.”

BA stated it was widespread apply for the airline trade to hold further gasoline on some flights.

The airline stated for BA this is applicable primarily to short-haul locations “the place there are appreciable worth variations between European airports”.

It stated the extra emissions from the airline represented roughly 2% of the entire additional emissions generated by all airways tankering gasoline in Europe, primarily based on analysis by Eurocontrol.

‘Questionable’

BA identified that since 2012 all flights inside Europe had been lined by the EU Emissions Buying and selling System.

It added that from 2020 the corporate would offset all CO2 emissions from its UK home flights.

Easyjet stated it had lowered the extent of tankering in recent times and that it solely came about on a tiny proportion of flights for operational and business causes.

Eurocontrol, the physique which coordinates air visitors management for Europe, has calculated that tankering in Europe resulted in 286,000 tonnes of additional gasoline being burnt yearly, and the emission of an extra 901,000 tonnes of carbon dioxide.

It calculates that the apply saved airways a complete of €265m (£228m) a 12 months.

Eurocontrol described the apply as “questionable” at a time when aviation is being challenged for its contribution to local weather change.

Panorama: Can Flying Go Inexperienced? is on BBC1 at 20:30 GMT on 11 November.