It is a query I could not keep away from as I drove throughout central England in a borrowed automobile powered by a hydrogen gasoline cell.
The Hyundai ix35 was quick, eerily quiet – they’ve put in a bit digital jingle so you may inform while you’ve switched it on – and there was a reassuring 230 miles (370 km) left on the clock.
And better of all, I drove with the smug information that when a car is powered by hydrogen, the one exhaust product is water.
Fairly a distinction from my very own 13-year-old, one-litre petrol engine: noisy, sluggish and undeniably soiled.
So why, I questioned, is that this clear, inexperienced know-how lagging far behind the hybrid and all-electric sectors?
The comparatively small hydrogen market is dominated by the Asian giants: Toyota, Honda and Hyundai.
In early October in Tokyo amid nice razzmatazz, Toyota unveiled its newest gasoline cell Mirai saloon, which it hopes to launch in late 2020.
European manufacturers together with BMW and Audi are additionally fine-tuning their very own hydrogen autos.
However it is a sector by which the upstart start-up can declare a modest place too.
Outdoors Llandrindod Wells, a small market city in central Wales, Riversimple goals to lease, not promote, its futuristic hydrogen gasoline cell autos to a strictly native market.
They’ve simply two automobiles on the street up to now, with Numbers three and four beneath building in Riversimple’s meticulously clear manufacturing facility.
“The automobile’s referred to as the Rasa – as in tabula rasa, or clear slate,” says the corporate’s founder and chief government, Hugo Spowers.
“We’re utilizing gasoline cells off the shelf: ours was made for fork-lifts for Walmart warehouses.”
The Rasa will do a tidy 60mph (100km/h) and has a spread of round 300 miles (480km) on a single 1.5 kg hydrogen tank.
“In purely calorific phrases,” Spowers concludes, “our automobile is doing the equal of 250 miles to the gallon.”
That sounds spectacular – so how do hydrogen powered automobiles work?
On the coronary heart of the automobile is a gasoline cell, the place hydrogen and oxygen are mixed to generate an electrical present, and the one by-product is water. There are not any transferring elements within the gasoline cell, so they’re extra environment friendly and dependable than a standard combustion engine.
Whereas the automobiles themselves don’t generate any gases that contribute to world warming, the method of creating hydrogen requires vitality – usually from fossil gasoline sources. So hydrogen’s inexperienced credentials are beneath query.
After which there’s the query of security. Hydrogen is a notoriously explosive fuel.
That is why producers disclose loads of reassuring element on their web sites.
The Toyota Mirai, for instance, boasts triple-layer hydrogen tanks succesful, the corporate says, of absorbing 5 occasions as a lot crash vitality as a metal petrol tank.
The dual hydrogen tanks within the Honda Readability are equally strong that includes layers of aluminium and carbon fibre and designed to withstand each excessive stress and excessive warmth.
Nonetheless, not everyone seems to be satisfied.
EuroTunnel doesn’t permit “autos powered by any flammable gasses”, together with hydrogen, to make use of the hyperlink between the UK and France.
The Riversimple enterprise mannequin – a three-year mounted value lease aimed toward short-distance native drivers – is designed to negate the largest drawback affecting hydrogen automobiles: vary nervousness.
With simply 17 pumps throughout Britain, refuelling is a problem, so the business is caught.
The general public will not commit if they can not assure a refill wherever they should drive, however hydrogen manufacturing corporations are reluctant to put in costly pumps until there’s more likely to be a constant take-up.
Extra Expertise of Enterprise
In response to Jorgo Chatzimarkakis, secretary-general of the pro-hydrogen group H2Europe, a rustic like Germany has round 75 hydrogen fuelling stations – however there aren’t sufficient drivers.
He blames automobile markers for being sluggish to supply hydrogen-powered automobiles. He factors out that BMW is not launching one till 2022 and Audi in 2025. “That is positively fairly late,” he says.
Mr Chatzimarkakis needs to prioritise a pan-European community of 20 to 30 pumps aligned alongside a “north-south hall” to allow hydrogen-powered autos – particularly bigger freight-bearing lorries – to journey freely the place enterprise wants dictate.
The Hydrogen4ClimateAction convention in Brussels in mid-October led to funding pledges by European governments of greater than €50bn (£43bn; $56bn) in hydrogen analysis and infrastructure.
“We at H2Europe are match-makers as a result of it is a co-operative job – it can’t be completed by business alone; it can’t be completed by politics alone,” Mr Chatzimarkakis says.
That collaboration is clear in California, which is experiencing the flip-side of the automobile/pump imbalance: there are queues at filling stations.
If you happen to go to the web site of the Various Fuels Information Middle, a part of the US Division of Power, and click on on “fuelling station areas”, you may get 42 outcomes – all in California.
“We’re laser-focused on constructing out an infrastructure to refill zero-emission autos,” says Patricia Monahan, science and engineering specialist on the California Power Fee (CEC).
As importantly, California is dedicated to incentives for each producers and customers within the gasoline cell sector, she says.
Anybody shopping for a brand new hydrogen automobile will get an incentive of $2,500, with related subsidies from each the CEC and the state’s Air Sources Board aimed toward persuading heavy-duty car corporations to look into zero-emission options.
“We’re actually testing out for the world,” Ms Monahan says, “the best way to develop an infrastructure to refuel these autos, and insurance policies to incentivise their manufacturing.”
In reality, even California could also be behind the curve.
In response to Andy Walker, technical advertising director at Johnson Matthey Gas Cell within the UK – itself a sector pioneer since 2003 – a number of Asian nations are making dramatic commitments to hydrogen.
“The Chinese language authorities has a goal of greater than one million gasoline cell autos on Chinese language roads by 2020, serviced by over a thousand hydrogen refuelling stations,” he says.
To that finish, Beijing has diminished subsidies to the battery sector and, in 2018 alone, invested $12.5bn on gasoline cell know-how and associated subsidies.
South Korea goals to go even additional, with a goal of 1.5 million gasoline cell autos.
And whereas Japan’s dedication is comparatively modest – a mere 800,000 new hydrogen autos – we will count on to see a giant showcase of hydrogen know-how on the 2020 Tokyo Olympics.
If these ambitions are even half-way realised, the remainder of the world will probably be enjoying catch-up.