Kashmir: The controversial deaths inflicting pressure

Asrar Ahmad Khan in hospital

Picture caption

The Indian military and Asrar’s household have conflicting variations of what brought on his deadly damage

There have been conflicting accounts of the variety of deaths in Indian-administered Kashmir, and the way they had been brought on, for the reason that area was stripped of its autonomy six weeks in the past. The BBC’s Yogita Limaye seems at some instances within the metropolis of Srinagar.


Seventeen-year-old Asrar Ahmad Khan was on the road outdoors his house on 6 August when he obtained an damage that led to his demise in hospital 4 weeks later.

Described as a “brilliant pupil” who cherished sport, the circumstances surrounding his demise have develop into one of many newest factors of dispute within the restive area the place conflicting narratives of occasions are steadily turning into the norm.


His father, Firdous Ahmad Khan, alleges that Asrar was enjoying cricket together with his associates when he was struck on the pinnacle by a teargas canister and lead pellets. One among his associates who was with him on the time says that he was fired at by Indian paramilitary troops who had been withdrawing for the night.

Asrar’s medical report states he died of accidents attributable to pellets, and the blast of a teargas shell. However India’s high military commander in Kashmir, Lt Gen KJS Dhillon, has stated that Asrar was hit by a stone, ostensibly thrown by Kashmiri protesters at armed forces.

The Kashmir police have instructed the BBC that in addition they stand by this assertion. They’ve known as the hospital’s report ambiguous, and stated it wants additional investigation.

Picture caption

Asrar’s medical report states he died of accidents attributable to pellets

Picture caption

An X-ray of Asrar’s cranium, with pellets seen within the high left hand nook of the scan

The incident passed off a day after the Indian authorities introduced that the area would lose its particular standing and be break up into two federally-run territories.

Within the days main as much as the shock announcement, tens of hundreds of further Indian troops had been deployed, a significant Hindu pilgrimage was cancelled, faculties and faculties had been shut, vacationers had been ordered to go away, phone and web companies had been suspended and regional political leaders had been positioned underneath home arrest.

India’s Kashmir transfer: Two views
Viewpoint: Why Modi’s Kashmir transfer is broadly supported in India

A report card displaying that Asrar had scored 84% in his tenth grade college examinations, and an previous newspaper with a photograph of him being awarded a cricket trophy, are among the many household’s most prized possessions.

“Does [Indian Prime Minister Narendra] Modi really feel my ache? Has he stated sorry for this? Has he condemned it?’ Asrar’s father requested the BBC.

“Tomorrow there will likely be extra deaths. In Kashmir at this time, there is no such thing as a accountability,” he added.

Picture caption

Asrar was described as a brilliant pupil and his report card is amongst his household’s prized possessions

The Indian authorities says that not a single life has been misplaced as a consequence of motion by safety forces since Kashmir’s particular standing was revoked. Nevertheless, it has stated that two folks, together with Asrar, have died after being hit by stones thrown by anti-government protesters.

Based on the federal government, three others – two nomadic goatherds within the Tral space of southern Kashmir and one shopkeeper from Srinagar – have been killed by armed insurgents.

The shopkeeper, 60-year-old Ghulam Mohammad, was reportedly sitting inside his store together with his spouse on the night of 29 August when he was shot useless by three folks, who then escaped on a motorbike.

Media playback is unsupported in your system

Media caption“Crushed and tortured” by the Indian military

There was hypothesis that he was killed as a result of he didn’t heed warnings by militant teams in opposition to opening his store. Kashmir’s Director Basic of Police Dilbagh Singh has stated that pamphlets warning folks in opposition to opening outlets, banks and petrol stations are being distributed by militant teams.

The BBC visited Mr Mohammad’s household however they had been too afraid to talk. Police instructed us they had been nonetheless investigating the motive behind his homicide.

However different folks say that the federal government’s “official figures” don’t account for the unnatural deaths of their family members in latest days.

Learn extra on Kashmir:

Amongst them is Rafiq Shagoo, who instructed the BBC he was having tea together with his spouse Fehmeeda Bano of their two-storey home within the Bemina space of Srinagar on 9 August when clashes between protesters and safety forces broke out within the neighbourhood.

Tear fuel – generally utilized by safety forces to dispel protests – crammed their house and Fehmeeda, 34, started to choke, he stated.

“She instructed me she was having bother respiratory. So I rushed her to the hospital. She saved asking me ‘what’s taking place to me’, and was very scared. The docs tried arduous, however she could not be saved.”

Picture copyright
Getty Photos

Picture caption

There have been protests regardless of the clampdown within the area

Ms Bano’s medical report states she died of poisonous fuel inhalation. Her husband is now planning to file a petition in court docket to ask for an investigation into his spouse’s demise.

The circumstances surrounding the demise of 60-year-old Mohammad Ayub Khan within the Safakadal space of Srinagar are similar to that of Ms Bano.

Mr Khan’s buddy Fayaz Ahmad Khan stated he was passing by the world on 17 August when clashes broke out.

He instructed the BBC that he noticed two tear fuel canisters land close to Mr Khan’s ft. His buddy was rushed to a hospital, however docs stated he was already useless. No medical report has been given to the household.

The police instructed us that it was a hearsay that Mr Khan had died from inhaling teargas smoke.

Regardless of the lockdown within the area, and the frequent imposition of curfew-like circumstances, protests in opposition to the federal government and safety forces have occurred and have usually turned violent.

Picture copyright
Getty Photos

Picture caption

A shopkeeper who opened for enterprise is believed to have been killed by armed insurgents

Hospitals have been tight-lipped about what number of casualties they’ve obtained. Lots of these injured have chosen to not go to correct medical services to get handled, as a result of they worry they is likely to be arrested for taking part in protests.

The federal government is already believed to have detained hundreds of individuals together with activists, native politicians and businessmen. Many have been shifted to jails in cities outdoors the area.

However despite the fact that it is arduous to evaluate how many individuals have died or have been injured, it’s clear that the dimensions of the unrest has been a lot smaller than Kashmir has witnessed earlier than.

“It’s in sharp distinction to earlier disturbances of 2008, 2010 and 2016 the place a lot of folks misplaced their lives,” governor Satya Pal Malik instructed reporters.

“All safety forces have labored day and evening to make sure that normalcy may be progressively restored with out inflicting hurt to people,” he added.

Many argue, nevertheless, that the communications blackout and army clampdown are the actual causes public anger will not be on full show.

It is unclear when the restrictions imposed in Kashmir will likely be totally lifted – and what’s more likely to occur when they’re.